Nov
19
2007

Does Hip-Hop Belong in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame?

flash.jpg

San Fransisco Chronicle’s music critic Joel Selvin is getting all bent out of shape because two hip-hop acts were nominated for induction into next year’s Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Part of the reason for Selvin refused to vote for anyone this year, partly because two of the nominees, Afrika Bambaataa and Beastie Boys, probably belong in a Hip-Hop Hall of Fame.

The prejudiced critic also bitched about Grandmaster Flash & Furious Five’s induction, which made them the first hip-hop act to ever receive the honor. Word on the streets is that Rolling Stone boss and hip-hop groupie Jann Wenner insisted on inducting Flash and ‘em even though they didn’t receive enough votes. Obviously, Wenner was getting sick and tired of not having any hip-hop inductees.

Selvin, on the other hand, doesn’t think any hip-hop artist belongs in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. I agree with him. We don’t need awards from white folks to validate our standards. Isn’t that why you have the VH1 Hip-Hop Honors? And don’t get me started on the true originators of Rock and Roll.


5 Responses

1. J to the AAP Says:

Funny thing is that Selvin thinks the only deserving nominee is Madonna. I’d say the Beasties have more R&R in ‘em than Madonna so I’m venturing a guess and say HipHop is just a ‘lower artform’ in his opinion. While that’s utter crap I do agree with you that HipHop shouldn’t be all that concerned with the approval of the Hall Of Fame

2. mack man Says:

fuck you. always gotta bring it back to the white man shit. the hite man this the white man that

fuck you

the last 5 hip hop shows i been to, in philly mind you, have been over 75% white people

wu, gza, black starr.. the list goes on

so fuck you racist bastards.

that white guy who doesnt want hip hop in the hall of fame is not ME.

so take your “white man” bullshit and shove it up your ass

3. Rizoh Says:

^Obviously you can read, but you lack comprehension skills. Who said this was about “the white man”?

4. Chris Says:

As resident whitey around these parts I figured I’d drop my thoughts into the ring. I honestly think that there is a place for hip hop in the R&R HOF. Hip hop is as much rock and roll as over 50% of the Hall’s members…

In the past five years The Ronettes, Miles Davis, Buddy Guy, The O’Jays and Isaac Hayes (just to name a few) were all inducted and I’m not sure that I’d call a single one of them traditional rock and roll acts.

With that - I think that what is and has been typically considered eligible for nomination has been anything from the blues on…so I think the term Rock and Roll HOF is a bit misleading when in fact it has been proven to be the Popular Music Hall of Fame.

Beasties - IN

Bambaataa - IN

and yes,

Madonna - IN

5. John Says:

Man come on, they support the real orgings of Rock, Little richard, Chuck Berry, Bo Diddley are all in and what do you have against white people, today’s people can’t do shit about shit the happend 200 years ago…



Leave a Comment

Automatically add your My.Rawkus profile avatar and a link to your profile. Simply use the email address and password of your My.Rawkus account. Not a member? Signup for FREE!


Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Who Run It?

The Focus


Twitter


The Rap Up Community

THE RAP UP RSS FEED

  RSS